• States
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Michigan
    • Minnesota
    • Missouri
    • Nebraska
    • North Dakota
    • Ohio
    • South Dakota
    • Wisconsin
  • Seasons
    • Spring
    • Summer
    • Fall
    • Winter
  • Activities
    • Exciting Cities
    • Food And Drink
    • Outdoor Adventures
    • Where To Stay
  • About Me
  • Contact Us
  • Search
  • Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Midwest Explored Logo

Learn how to easily plan your dream trip to the Midwest!

  • States
    • Illinois
    • Indiana
    • Iowa
    • Kansas
    • Michigan
    • Minnesota
    • Missouri
    • Nebraska
    • North Dakota
    • Ohio
    • South Dakota
    • Wisconsin
  • Seasons
    • Spring
    • Summer
    • Fall
    • Winter
  • Activities
    • Exciting Cities
    • Food And Drink
    • Outdoor Adventures
    • Where To Stay
  • About Me
  • Contact Us
  • Search
A mushroom pizza in a wood fired oven in an article about restaurants in Door County

15 Best Restaurants In Door County WI You Must Try

Home » 15 Best Restaurants In Door County WI You Must Try

October 28, 2026 by //  by Midwest Explored

Looking for the best restaurants in Door County, Wisconsin? From traditional fish boils and cosy supper clubs to waterfront restaurants and farm-to-table dining, this beautiful part of Wisconsin has some wonderful places to eat.

Door County sits on a peninsula between Lake Michigan and Green Bay, and it’s one of my favourite places to explore in the Midwest. With its pretty waterfront towns, beautiful scenery and laid-back atmosphere, it’s one of those picture-perfect places.

And food is a big part of the experience here. You’ll find historic inns serving traditional Wisconsin dishes, restaurants making the most of locally grown ingredients, and some wonderfully unusual places to eat. There is even a Swedish restaurant with goats grazing on its roof!

There are so many wonderful things to do in Door County, from exploring beautiful beaches to visiting historic lighthouses and charming little towns.

Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner overlooking the water, somewhere casual for lunch, or a traditional Door County fish boil, I’ve put together 15 restaurants of what I think are the best on the area.

Let’s take a look at some of the best places to eat in Door County.

The harbor town of Sister Bay with fall colors and boats. The article is about restaurants in Door County.

Best Restaurants in Door County at a Glance

RestaurantLocationBest For
Osteria Tre TassiEllison BayItalian dining and date nights
Al Johnson’sSister BaySwedish food and goats on the roof
CHOPSister BaySteaks and lake views
Roots Inn & KitchenSister BayVegan-friendly comfort food
Pearl Wine CottageEphraimWine and small plates
White Gull InnFish CreekTraditional Door County fish boils
Wild TomatoFish CreekWood-fired pizza
ChivesBaileys HarborFarm-to-table dining
Ember at The LandmarkEgg HarborCajun-inspired food and bay views
The English InnFish CreekTraditional supper club dining
Sister Bay BowlSister BayFish fry and vintage bowling
Old Post OfficeEphraimFish boils and waterfront sunsets
Barringer’sFish CreekFine dining and steaks
Nightingale Supper ClubSturgeon BayClassic Wisconsin supper club
Blue BearEllison BayBreakfast, brunch and vegan options

15 Best Restaurants In Door County WI You Must Try

Osteria Tre Tassi – Ellison Bay

If you love Italian food and restaurants with an interesting past, Osteria Tre Tassi in Ellison Bay is well worth a visit.

Located in a historic building that was previously home to the much-loved Wickman House restaurant, Osteria Tre Tassi opened in 2024 and has brought a taste of Italy to this pretty Door County village.

The restaurant specialises in Italian and Mediterranean-inspired cuisine, with an emphasis on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. They even grow their own herbs and vegetables, making the most of the land surrounding the property.

Inside, the restaurant has a rustic but elegant feel, with a welcoming atmosphere that makes it a lovely place to spend an evening.

The menu focuses on seasonal ingredients and traditional Italian flavours, accompanied by a carefully selected wine list featuring Italian classics and other favourites. There are also craft cocktails if you fancy something a little different.

What I particularly like about Osteria Tre Tassi is its commitment to preserving the character of the historic building while bringing something new to the Door County dining scene.

If you’re looking for a relaxed but special evening meal, this is one of the restaurants in Door County to consider.

Reservations are recommended, especially during the busy summer months.

Al Johnson’s Swedish Restaurant & Butik -Sister Bay

Al Johnson’s is one of the Door County restaurants, that you must pay a visit to. This restaurant has been going for over 60 years and is quite legendary in these parts. Oh, and it has goats that live on the roof! Locals know it as ‘the restaurant with goats on the roof’. 

The menu is Swedish in nature, with dishes such as homemade Swedish meatballs, pickled herring and their famous Swedish pancakes served with lingonberries.

The place is more of a complex than a restaurant with a shop selling Swedish items, an outside bar, and an outdoor space where families can enjoy lawn games, drinks, and food on the green space. If you have children, they are catered to really well here. 

The main restaurant is open from 7 am until 3 pm with the bar and outside spaces staying open longer into the evening. 

Oh, and if you thought I was kidding about the goats they even have a goat cam. It’s one of the Sister Bay restaurants you must see with your own eyes.

Sister Bay itself is well worth exploring, and there are plenty of other Door County attractions to discover while you’re here.

Swedish meatballs with mashed potatoes and sauce on aplate in an article about restaurants in Door County

Chop – Sister Bay Is One Of The Best Restaurants In Door County

If you love a good steak then this is the best restaurant in Sister Bay is for you. While there is more on offer this eatery is all about steak in a relaxed informal setting. 

It’s a trendy-looking restaurant all wood and metal and it has a great patio with lake views. The restaurant has also been renovated and now offers an early dining three-course menu and happy hour specials in its expanded bar.

Here you will find some of the highest quality steaks, fish and seafood cooked to perfection and pretty much any way you want. 

There is nothing fancy about this place it’s just about great ingredients and great food in a great setting. It’s the perfect place to eat after a day of sightseeing. 

A steak with a side of salad with a side of sauce.

Roots Inn & Kitchen – Sister Bay

There are two things this restaurant is best known for. One is the bratwurst and two is the incredible vegan selection of foods. This is comfort plant-based food and it’s oh so good. 

They work with the local farmers and community entrepreneurs to put local products on the plate. 

The inn that the restaurant is in is historic, quirky, and homely.  Roots Inn & Kitchen operates seasonally, so it’s worth checking their website for the latest opening hours before visiting.

If you are vegan or curious about how good vegan food can be then this is the restaurant in Door County to visit.

Roast cauliflower and vegetables in taco shells on a plate. The article is about restaurants in Door County.

Pearl Wine Cottage- Ephraim

This place is hard to describe because I guarantee it’s not like any other place you have been. It’s a small casual wine-focused restaurant. 

What makes this Door County restaurant unusual is that it is inside an old cottage the owners restored.  It also doesn’t take reservations as it expects guests to arrive early and stay late. It’s almost like you are eating at someone’s house here. 

Outdoor seating is available but if you can go inside because it’s a whole other experience. They serve what is called ‘pearl plates’ which are more like tasting plates with special attention paid to organic and biodynamic options. 

There is something just so wholesome about this place. The owners care about the property, they care about your experience and they care what you are eating and drinking, it really is a delight.

Pearl Wine Cottage is open seasonally, so make sure you check their website before planning your visit.

If you enjoy trying local wines, there are also some wonderful wineries in Wisconsin, including several in Door County.

Cheese and tomatoes on a plate with tomatoes on the side. Served at one of the best restaurants in Door County.

White Gull Inn – Fish Creek 

If you want to try a traditional Door County fish boil then this is the place to do it. It really is something everyone should experience at least once. 

A fish boil is essentially freshly caught Lake Michigan whitefish cooked outside over an open fire. It’s a local tradition passed down from the Scandinavian settlers of the Peninsula. 

Fish boils are served here Wednesday, Friday, Saturday, and Sunday evenings from May through October and on Friday evenings the rest of the year.

Not into fish? The inn also serves breakfast, lunch and candlelight dinners, and there is a chicken option available at the traditional fish boils.

And the local cherry pie here is delicious too. 

A fish on a plate with grilled zucchinis. The article is about restaurants in Door County.

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille -Fish Creek

It might seem a little odd to have a pizza restaurant on this list but this one is worth it. These lovely wood-fired pizzas available in Sister Bay and Fish Creek offer something a little different. 

Many of the pizzas include products from local farms so expect to find some unusual concoctions such as wild duck and pumpkin sausage and the Fun Guy with five types of mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions.

The restaurant is focused on two things. One, using sustainable products to create an affordable dining experience. And two, developing a broader definition of service.

Now owned by local couple Matthew and Karla Sagorac, Wild Tomato continues its commitment to fresh, sustainable ingredients and giving back to the Door County community. One of the best restaurants in Fish Creek you must go to.

Both locations are also close to some lovely beaches in Door County, perfect for exploring before or after your meal.

A mushroom pizza in a wood fired oven in an article about restaurants in Door County

Chives – Baileys Harbor

Located in Downtown Baileys Harbor, Chives is all about food quality, presentation, and value.  It’s an upscale farm-to-table experience and one of the best restaurants in Door County.

The ingredients are fresh, seasonal, and local. Chef and owner JR Schoenfeld is known for his abundant use of vegetables. 

The menu contains things like Burgundy Braised Beef Cheeks, Mussels and Chips, and Chicken Marsala.

And the desserts here are fantastic too. Reservations are recommended at this Bailey’s Harbor restaurant.  

Mussels in a dish with a side of fries in an article about restaurants in Door County

Ember at The Landmark Resort – Egg Harbor

If you love Cajun-inspired food, Ember at The Landmark Resort in Egg Harbor is one of the restaurants in Door County worth trying.

Formerly The Fireside Restaurant, the restaurant joined forces with Ember in 2026, bringing chef Blake Schar’s New Orleans-inspired cooking to a beautiful new setting overlooking the bay.

The menu continues to feature creative dishes influenced by Blake’s Louisiana roots, alongside American favourites and seasonal specials.

And one of the best things about the new location is the view. Situated at The Landmark Resort, Ember offers panoramic views of Green Bay, making it a lovely place to enjoy dinner after a day exploring Door County.

If you’re looking for somewhere that combines interesting flavours with a great setting, Ember is well worth considering.

Jambalaya on a silver plate with a fork. You can see rice and sausage.

The English Inn-Fish Creek 

Think elegant supper club and old English pub and that gives you a feel for this place. It’s cozy, dark with lots of wood, and has that real homely feel. 

The food is more American, upgraded with lots of steak and seafood cooked in various ways. While there are English notes running through the menu don’t expect to find traditional bangers and mash. 

If you like good produce cooked the way you like it then this is the place to come. Think broiled pork chops, prime rib, and beef liver. 

They do also serve nightly featured items and the beef wellington has quite a good reputation. If you love good meat this is one of the restaurants in Door County for you.

Beef wellington with broccoli on a plate. The article is about restaurants in Door County.

Sister Bay Bowl – Sister Bay

If you want to experience a traditional Wisconsin supper club with something a little different, Sister Bay Bowl is the place to go.

This family-owned restaurant has been part of Sister Bay for generations, and it’s something of a local institution. The Willems family have been welcoming visitors here since 1958, and the restaurant is now in its fourth generation.

The menu is full of traditional Wisconsin favourites, including hand-cut steaks, prime rib, broasted chicken and their famous Friday night fish fry.

But what makes this restaurant rather unusual is that it also has a bowling alley.

Yes, you can enjoy a traditional supper club dinner and then head over for a game on the vintage bowling lanes. It’s a wonderful combination of good food, family fun and a little nostalgia.

There is also a bar serving classic Wisconsin cocktails and an outdoor patio bar during the summer months.

If you’re looking for somewhere relaxed, friendly and full of local character, Sister Bay Bowl is one of the Door County restaurants worth visiting.

One Of The Best Restaurants In Door County Is The Old Post Offcie- Ephraim

This award-winning Door County restaurant is in the beautiful historic 1900s post office and boasts waterfront dining.

The large windows look right over the lake and the view is beautiful.

They serve breakfast and host evening fish boils. These boils include fish, potatoes onions, homemade bread, and cherry pie. And if you don’t like fish swap for chicken or ribs. 

The restaurant is open seasonally from May through October, and reservations are recommended for the fish boils. Arrive a little early to watch the traditional boil-over, which is all part of the experience.

And the best bit is the sunsets here are worth the trip alone. 

Broiled white fish with potatoes and corn on a plate

Barringer’s Restuarnt -Fish Creek

Owned and operated by the same chef who owns Chives, you know this place is going to be good. This is a supper club steakhouse experience. 

It’s fine dining here with steaks, fresh seafood, and some delicious and generous side portions. You can dine in the historic dining room or in the outside bar. 

It’s chic but welcoming and very fresh-looking. On the patio bar, you will find things like hamburgers and hot dogs but all with something a little bit unusual and extra. 

Barringer’s was traditionally a summer ice cream shop designed by architect Charles Gabertin in 1910. It later turned into a coffee, gift, and ice cream shop in the ’40s and was turned into a restaurant in the ’80s. 

It’s an unusual building that stands out and is fondly loved by locals. And contains one of the best restaurants in Fish Creek.

A seafood platter with shrimps and calamari. The article is about restaurants in Door County.

Nightingale Supper Club – Sturgeon Bay

This is one of the Sturgeon Bay Restaurants you need to pay a visit to. Serving the locals since 1913 this restaurant has stood the test of time.

This Door County restaurant serves a variety of steaks, seafood, poultry, salads, and soups. They also serve a traditional Friday night fish fry, with choices including cod, perch, walleye and locally caught whitefish.

It’s a warm and welcoming Sturgeon Bay restaurant with an attentive staff. You will leave this place with a big smile and a happy belly.

Grilled chicken with potatoes and green beans in an article about restaurants in Door County

Blue Bear – Ellison Bay

If you’re looking for somewhere a little different for breakfast or brunch in Door County, Blue Bear in Ellison Bay is well worth a visit.

This relaxed restaurant is all about fresh, locally sourced ingredients and food made from scratch. The menu features a mixture of breakfast and brunch favourites, with plenty of vegan and gluten-free options too.

They also serve speciality coffees, seasonal drinks and cocktails, making it a lovely place to start the day before heading out to explore Door County.

There are two outdoor patios, including one where dogs are welcome, so it’s a great spot to enjoy a leisurely meal when the weather is good.

If you love good food in a relaxed setting, Blue Bear is one of the Door County restaurants to add to your list.

A burrito wrap filled with vegetables in an article about restaurants in Door County

As you can see, when it comes to restaurants in Door County, there are so many to choose from. If you have visited this area or are local, please add your favourites in the comments below so others can discover them too.

Some Door County restaurants are seasonal, so it’s always worth checking opening hours and making reservations before you visit, especially during the busy summer months.

Whichever of these Door County restaurants you visit, I know you will have a fabulous time. Visiting Door County and its incredible eateries is truly one of the best things to do in Wisconsin.

Fall is my favourite time to visit, and Door County is one of the most beautiful places to experience fall in Wisconsin. The colours here are just divine.

If you’re planning to stay for a few days, take a look at my guide to the best resorts in Door County to help you find somewhere to stay.

Filed Under: Food And Drink, Wisconsin Tagged With: Food and drink, Travel, USA, Wisconsin

Previous Post: «A spread of Middle Eastern food. There is kabobs, a quinoa salad, hummus, pita, pomegranates, and figs. The foods are on silver dishes. Its similar to meals you find in restaurants in Detroit. 15 Best Restaurants In Detroit MI You Must Try
Next Post: 6 Best National Parks In South Dakota For Your Bucket List Carvings of men in mountains. Best national parks in South Dakota»

Primary Sidebar

About Me

Hi. I’m Linda. Welcome to Midwest Explored. I was born and raised in the Midwest. This area of the United States is very underrated, and often passed over when it comes to vacation destinations or corporate events. Here I am sharing the Midwest with you to entice you to take advantage of all it has to offer!

Site Footer

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from Qualifying Purchases.
Midwest Explored Privacy Policy: https://midwestexplored.com/privacy-policy/